Smart Phillip (Mazaný Filip) – Václav Marhoul, 2003

Humphrey Bogart. Elliot Gould. Robert Mitchum. Dick Powell. Danny Glover. James Caan. Many great actors have put their unique spin on the role of Raymond Chandler’s classic sleuth, Phillip Marlowe. Then there’s Tomáš Hanák in Mazaný Filip, who looks about as enthusiastic in the part as a PE teacher who’s been browbeaten by his wife into taking part in a murder mystery LARP, when he could be away on a weekend jolly with his rugby teammates instead.

Starting off by criticizing Hanák’s awkward performance is a bit like standing in front of your house after it’s been flattened by a tornado, and worrying that it’s been ages since you last mowed the lawn. It is maybe the least of the problems with this painfully weak detective spoof, which are so wide-ranging and catastrophic that it’s tough to know where to begin. So it might as well be with the lead.

Smart Philip DVD

Buy Smart Philip from Amazon HERE

The plot of Mazaný Filip is a mish-mash of Chandler-esque story beats. Hanák plays Marlowe, a world-weary detective who spends time between cases peering out through the Venetian blinds in his office, or taking generous slugs from the bottle of liquor that he keeps in his filing cabinet. He’s approached by a character who calls himself “Charlie Brown” (Pavel Liska in an almost unwatchably bizarre performance, which is still not the worst acting in this movie) to find his twin brother…

I kind of phased out of the plot after that, as I was constantly distracted by another mortifyingly unfunny joke or crass visual pun. Yet the plot was so generic that even if I zoned out for five or ten minutes, I still knew roughly where I was in the story when I tuned back in. Suffice to say it follows the usual twists and turns of detective noir, featuring all the expected character stereotypes – the villains, the crime bosses, the goons, the violent cops, etc, etc. And then of course there’s the dame, because there’s one in every story…

Vilma Cibulková plays Vilma, the film’s femme fatale. Her performance might actually be the best in the film, but she seems totally miscast. A femme fatale’s look is intrinsic to her purpose in detective noir. She’s bad news and the protagonist usually knows it, but she’s so alluring that he can’t help get involved anyway. Cibulková seems around 10-15 years too old for the role. It’s like the casting director went out to hire a Lana Turner impersonator, but the impersonator was busy – so they hired the Lana Turner impersonator’s mum instead. She just looks uncanny.

I knew that I was going to have problems with Mazaný Filip from the moment I realized that it was a “parody” of detective films. I still couldn’t prepare myself for how bad it would be – the spoof comedy is long past its heyday of Young Frankenstein or Airplane, and this exists somewhere down in the subgenre’s bilges with abominations like Fifty Shades of Black and Epic Movie.

The visual puns are so lame, usually relying on naff anachronistic movie references in lieu of real jokes. Take the opening scene – the caption tells us that we’re in Los Angeles, 1937, and in the night sky above the city a bat flutters. Momentarily it flies in front of the full moon, creating the Bat Signal. That’s it, that’s the joke – hey guys, recognize this pop culture reference? Get it? Funny, huh?

Not really. There’s a whole bunch of these inflection-free movie references scattered throughout the film. Without paying too much attention I picked up on nods to One Flew Over the Cuckoo’s Nest, Marathon Man, Batman, and The Matrix. There’s a bullet time gag, which was also parodied in Scary Movie. It kind of worked in Scary Movie, because Scary Movie is set in the same era that The Matrix was released. Every time one of these references appeared on the screen, it pulled me further out of the film.

Here’s why. In Who Framed Roger Rabbit, Eddie Valiant interacts with various cartoon characters. It’s absurd, silly and bordering on the surreal, but it works because the film adheres to an internal logic – the Toons are from the same era as the genre the film is paying homage to, so it makes sense.

Now, if Zemeckis had chosen to throw in He-Man, Skeletor and a few Thundercats as well, just because they were popular around the time the film was released, he would be betraying the film world he’s created. Just chucking in random movie references for the sake of a gag pisses away any sense of congruity.

It wouldn’t be so bad if director and screenwriter Václav Marhoul could settle on a consistent tone. The story line is far too serious and moribund to support ZAZ-style sight gags, and the visual puns don’t come frequently enough to enliven the pedestrian pacing of the plot. Scenes drag on ponderously, seemingly long after the plot point or  joke has been delivered. The movie is a shade under 100 minutes long – a more rigorous edit could’ve made it zip along better without really losing anything important.

Several of my Czech friends actually like Mazaný Filip, and they reliably inform me that the verbal wordplay is lost in translation. I was aware that the subtitles on my copy were pretty wobbly, so I can totally buy that. However, that doesn’t excuse the limp pacing, unimaginative mystery, am-dram level acting, appalling racial stereotypes (including some of the worst blackface I’ve ever seen), and total lack of understanding of the genre it is supposed to be spoofing. It would be offensive if it wasn’t so boring – in short, Mazaný Filip puts the “sleep” into The Big Sleep



Author: leerobertadams

Lee is an English writer, blogger and film critic living in Brno, Czech Republic. When not watching and writing about movies, he loves football, reading, eating out, and enjoying his adopted home city with his girlfriend and two children.

4 thoughts on “Smart Phillip (Mazaný Filip) – Václav Marhoul, 2003”

  1. You didn’t get anything. Hanak is totally wooden – intentionally. It illustrates the main character’s alcoholism, actually Hanak is/was an alcoholic. Liska looks like an idiot, intentionally. Almost all his characters were idiotic, his life-role was in movie “Return of idiot”, maybe he actually is an idiot. Cibulkova is a faded bloom – intentionally. The am-dram level, silly black face, Batman, bullet time in 30’s, all of these are just a part of parody. The movie is full of AAA-class Czech actors in side roles, it’s very funny and unusual to see them in such grotesque roles. Michael Palin said: “The only nations with sense of humour are Brits, and, for some strange reason, Czechs.” I’m very proud of that.
    There two things I could agree: 1) Lot of humour is lost in translation, but most of sentences are weird even for Czechs. 2) The storyline is too simple, and when it starts to work in the second half, the movie actually loses its’ drive.


    1. Yeah I got it, I just thought it was weak! I understood the noir archetypes they were trying to spoof, but I think it’s just been done better many times before. Perhaps that opening paragraph is a bit misleading – maybe it would’ve been better talking about send-ups of Marlowe-like sleuths like Peter Falk in Murder by Death or Steve Martin in Dead Men Don’t Wear Plaid rather than straight portrayals of the character. Thanks for reading and commenting, I appreciate it! I now face a difficult choice – do I revise an old review or do I leave it??


Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in: Logo

You are commenting using your account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s

%d bloggers like this: